The beliefs that shape a leader’s identity can provide consistency and stability, but they can also make it difficult to adapt. When a familiar leadership approach is closely tied to how someone sees themselves, changing their behaviour may mean questioning deeply held assumptions about who they are and what makes them effective.
Key takeaways
- Identity can support or limit leadership effectiveness. Beliefs that have served leaders well in the past may not suit their current team or environment.
- Good intentions don’t always match others’ experiences. Leaders may see themselves as fair, approachable or supportive without recognising how it is interpreted within their teams.
- Changing behaviour can challenge a leader’s sense of self. Exploring what they believe is at risk can help explain why familiar approaches are difficult to shift.
- Curiosity and feedback create opportunities for change. Helping leaders question assumptions, seek different perspectives and reflect on where their beliefs came from can open up new ways of leading.
Our identity is one of the strongest anchors we have. The answer to “I am a person who…” can shape how we interpret situations, make judgements about other people’s behaviour, and how open to change we might actually be.
In previous newsletters, we’ve explored the layers that shape culture, and how leaders respond to changing situations. This time, I want to look at something that can make adapting difficult: the beliefs leaders hold about themselves.
Our identity and beliefs shape communication, decision-making and discernment. Staying true to who we are can be helpful to guide us through uncertain and complex situations. A team may not like every decision, but if they feel the behaviour is authentic and not out of character, they can trust that it is at least consistent.
That consistency can be a stabiliser people rely on while all else seems unstable. But what starts as consistency can become inflexibility when being adaptable is needed. Confidence in our judgement can make it harder to question our assumptions, and trusting in ‘this is who I am’ can be our reason to hold on to behaviours that may not be serving the people around us.
Our sense of identity can be so strong that we reject information that challenges our status or sense of worth. Believing that our intentions are good, we trust we are doing the right thing.
If we find ourselves being selective about whose feedback or advice we listen to, it may be worth considering whether our identity is protecting our existing perspective.
How rigid beliefs can shape culture
Here are a few examples of how deeply held identity and beliefs can influence the way leaders operate and how their teams experience work.
“To make sure it’s done right, I need close oversight.”
This may have been an effective approach in a previous role or environment. But when applied to a capable team, it can limit agency and growth. Managers may stop making decisions for themselves, and the leader becomes increasingly relied upon for direction.
“I’m approachable and my door is always open.”
A leader may genuinely believe they are approachable. But that belief can make it harder to recognise the power dynamics that stop people from speaking up. An open door puts the onus on everyone else to act and does not necessarily mean people feel safe walking through it.
“I treat everyone the same.”
This may come from a deeply held commitment to fairness. But different people and situations need different things. Treating everyone the same can sometimes overlook individual needs, capability, experience or circumstances.
Some beliefs are also shaped by the environments in which leaders have developed. Expectations about authority, respect and what is considered reasonable behaviour can become so familiar that they’re no longer questioned.
What was accepted in a previous era, industry or organisation may no longer align with the people, expectations or environment a leader is working within today.
When identity gets in the way of change
If you’re working with a leader or manager whose beliefs are impacting their team, it can be difficult to know where to start.
The issue may not be a lack of knowledge or good intentions. The change being asked of them might challenge something they believe about who they are, how they lead, or what makes them effective.
A leader might understand that their managers need more autonomy, but can’t resist checking in for progress reports. If being involved in every decision is part of what makes them feel responsible or effective, changing that approach can challenge their sense of certainty and control.
One question worth exploring, when there is enough trust for an honest conversation, is:
What do you believe is at risk if you changed your approach?
For someone who sees themselves as knowledgable, it might be credibility. For someone who values certainty, it might be the risk of things going wrong. For someone who wants to be liked, it might be the risk of conflict.
If you’re interested in exploring this further, Kegan and Lahey’s Immunity to Change framework offers a useful way to understand the underlying beliefs and assumptions that can keep us stuck, even when we genuinely want to change.
Understanding what might be sitting underneath a belief is one thing. Helping someone question it requires curiosity, feedback and space to reflect.
A few ways to help leaders question the story
Encourage curiosity about what else is going on.
Ask which perspective they haven’t considered. What might they be assuming about the people or situation? What else could explain what they’re seeing? The aim is to expand their interpretation before settling on an answer.
Suggest feedback from different perspectives.
Encourage feedback from senior leaders, peers and direct reports. How do others experience their approach? Does that match how they see themselves? Without new information, our internal story keeps repeating.
Help them find someone who will challenge their thinking.
A mentor or coach can be valuable, not just to support and enable, but to question assumptions. Encourage them to find someone who can help them explore what they might be protecting or overlooking, rather than simply reinforcing what they already believe.
Explore where the belief came from.
Ask how the belief was formed. What experiences reinforced it? Was it useful in a previous role or environment? Is it still serving them, or is it constraining their potential?
Understanding where a belief came from can help a leader recognise why it feels difficult to change, and whether it is still useful in their current environment.
Leaders don’t need to abandon the beliefs that have shaped who they are. But as the people and environments around them change, they need to be willing to question whether those beliefs still hold true.
Helping a leader recognise this can open the door to different perspectives and responses. Sometimes a small shift in how a leader sees themselves can make a significant difference to how others experience them.